I’m home for a short while. It’s been an incredibly hectic first few days filled with my brother’s concerts, my cousin’s high school graduation, a family reunion, and various other functions in/around my parents’ house. Today, I found myself with some spare time. Finally.
I woke up at exactly 6. I haven’t been in the habit of doing that lately, but my dog stepped on me, so there we go. I woke up.
I moseyed my way downstairs, made a stop at the pantry, and decided that pancakes sounded good. A little bit of mixing and half an hour later, a fat stack of orange-cinnamon pancakes were sitting on the kitchen counter, waiting to be devoured. I made myself some tea, my dad made some coffee, and my entire family sat down for some breakfast. 6:45 a.m. My mom and I watched Good Morning America together, and she started bugging me about the lumps of unknown ingredients sitting in the freezer, ready to meet their maker. (Kraft?)
My family isn’t huge on cream cheese. For whatever reason, my parents have taken to spreading laughing cow cheese on bagels. So when I whipped up a cheesecake for some corporate potluck or something along those lines last Christmas, we had about half a Costco-sized box of cream cheese left over. I hate to waste food so… I froze it. I used bits of it over the first half of 2010. Some on the white pizza I made a few months back. Some for a cake frosting. But there were still two half-cup chunks in the freezer, and they were pretty sad looking. Ready for a pity killing.
Here’s the thing. I’ve never stuck with a cheesecake recipe. I’ve found some that I like, but none that I love. The one on the Philadelphia cream cheese box ended up tasting store-bought in a very unmemorable/generic way. Family and friends always seem to love it, but I’ve always been disappointed. So this one, I decided to wing.
Half a carton of light Daisy sour cream in the fridge (leftover from when I made spinach dip for my brother’s studio recital). About a cup (maybe a little more) of frozen cream cheese. FYI, cream cheese does not freeze particularly well. It won’t go bad in there, but the texture’s never quite the same. I didn’t mind that though. The dry ricotta-y consistency would serve my purposes just fine.
I creamed that sucker with three quarters a cup of sugar. The texture reminded me of raw chicken skin–not lumpy, but unappealingly bumpy. I added the zest of a lemon. Then I spotted an orange on the counter… “Eh…” I thought, “why not?” In went the zest of an orange as well. Fearing an overwhelmingly citrus-y cheesecake, I raided the pantry. In went a generous sprinkling of nutmeg and half a teaspoon of vanilla. Two eggs. I had a little taste test. Too sweet. The juice of half a lemon got squeezed into that, and it tasted about right to me. So I folded in a little flour, and poured it all into my everyday graham cracker crust (spiked with some cinnamon and nutmeg).
It’s baking in a 300 degree F oven right now. No water bath, sheerly because I’m feeling lazy. As obvious an add as it seems, I’ve never been one to add zest to cheesecake. This cheesecake could change my mind. That batter was pretty delicious… maybe that’ll be my new secret to cheesecake: freeze and thaw the cream cheese.
I may post pictures if this venture proves to be successful… We have some beautiful strawberries on hand. I think they’ll go great on top. Regardless of how happy or unhappy I am with this zesty little guy, I’m sure he’ll taste pretty good regardless, and I’m definitely looking forward to dessert tomorrow night
…but I’m still crossing my fingers that this will be the end of my journey for a cheesecake that is truly mine!